“Left an expensive coffee machine in apartment when away. Came back to it not working. My roommate was home.”
Left an expensive coffee machine in apartment when away. Came back to it not working. My roommate was home. He admits he used it but refuses to even share the cost of repair.
The Defendant has been summoned and has not yet filed a defense.
I want him to share the cost of repair.
Who's right?
Jury deliberation
- JUROR #4 · 21H AGO
Pretty clear this one. Unless there's something we're not hearing from the plaintiff.
- JUROR #8 · 21H AGO
If the roommate mishandled (whether intentionally or unintentionally) the coffee machine and broke it, the roommate must pitch in to repair or replace the machine.
- JUROR #16 · 20H AGO
Based on the available information, the defendant should contribute to the cost of repair. Especially since defendant admitted use of the coffee machine during plaintiff’s absence, and presumably has some knowledge of machine’s condition before it broke, AND without further explanation or comment from either parties, I believe defendant should contribute to repair or replacement of coffee machine.
- JUROR #20 · 19H AGO
I concur with Jurors 4, 8, and 16. We don't know the age or condition of said machine, let alone what it is and Model # to determine. Roomie needs to ante up and pay.
- JUROR #24 · 18H AGO
How old was the coffee machine?